His name is St. John Rivers. Every. Darn. Time.
I admit, after having read this book four or five times, this shouldn’t surprise me. The book is in stages. The childhood stage. The long and dreary Lowood School years. Thornfield, Thornfield, wonderful Thornfield, and then…. St. John Rivers. Sigh.
I understand that he’s a very important foil for Rochester. He is everything good, and straight, and narrow, but also everything cold, hard and passionateless. Actually, worse, he has passion, but denies it thoroughly. St. John Rivers is exactly as unappealing as Charlotte Brontë ever could have wanted, and that’s a fact. What’s also a fact is that it makes for slow reading. Trudging, more like.
Don’t get me wrong, this is my favorite book in the history of books (or at least in the history of books I’ve read, which is a decent number for my four-and-score years) but St. John Rivers is a drag. He just is. He’s more cringe-worthy than Mr. Collins of Pride and Prejudice, because at least Eliza isn’t listening carefully to every word Mr. Collins says.
I suppose I could always skip over St. John… but I never do. I just don’t roll that way. And if I did I might miss his sisters who I do adore. I honestly want to pluck him from the book sometimes, though. He’s just so unenjoyable to read. Though I suppose if he were gone, there’d be no one to save Jane from starving to death, would there? And we can’t have that, so St. John will have to stay, no matter how much I whine and resist him. Poor Rosamond Oliver. He really must have been pretty for her to fall for him like that.
~Lisa, who has six more books to finish (this one included) before hitting her goal of 52 books in 52 weeks. It may just happen this year!